Sugar Cookie Pudding Cups with Swirl Filling Recipe

If you’re looking for a fun, festive treat that’s as delightful to eat as it is to make, you’ve got to try my Sugar Cookie Pudding Cups with Swirl Filling Recipe. These little cups pack big flavor with soft sugar cookie bases and creamy, colorful cheesecake pudding swirls that will have your friends and family swooning. I absolutely love how this recipe combines simple ingredients to create a show-stopping dessert that’s perfect for holidays, parties, or just a sweet afternoon pick-me-up. Ready to make some magic in your kitchen? Let’s dive in!

this …

Ingredients You’ll Need

The magic of this Sugar Cookie Pudding Cups with Swirl Filling Recipe lies in its simplicity. Each ingredient works perfectly to create that soft cookie cup texture with creamy, dreamy pudding swirls on top. When shopping, look for quality refrigerated sugar cookie dough and a cheesecake pudding mix to make sure your flavors shine.

• Refrigerated sugar cookie dough: Buying it pre-made saves tons of time and ensures consistent flavor and texture.
• Instant cheesecake pudding mix: The cheesecake flavor adds richness that pairs beautifully with the sweet cookie base.
• 2% milk: Cold milk helps the pudding set up nice and thick without being overly rich.
• Red and green food coloring: Perfect for creating those pretty swirls, especially around holiday time—but feel free to use any colors you love!

Variations

One of my favorite things about the Sugar Cookie Pudding Cups with Swirl Filling Recipe is how easy it is to tweak it to suit your style and occasion. Whether you want to make it extra festive, lighter, or just more colorful, I’ve got you covered with some of my go-to variations.

• Flavor swaps: I’ve substituted the cheesecake pudding with chocolate or vanilla pudding to switch things up—each version brings its own charm.
• Food coloring fun: Try different color combos to match birthdays, seasons, or themed parties; I once made a pastel version for a baby shower that was a huge hit.
• Dietary tweaks: For dairy-free, almond or oat milk with a compatible instant pudding works well; and gluten-free cookie dough is another easy swap.
• Extra texture: For a little crunch, sprinkle crushed candy canes or colored sugar on top of the pudding swirls before chilling.

How to Make Sugar Cookie Pudding Cups with Swirl Filling Recipe

Step 1: Shaping and Baking the Cookie Cups

Start by preheating your oven to 350°F (175°C) and greasing a mini muffin pan with non-stick spray. I like to break the refrigerated sugar cookie dough into little 1-inch balls—this size makes the perfect little cups that hold enough pudding without being too big. Place each ball into the muffin pan, pressing slightly to fill the bottom. Bake for 10-12 minutes or until they’re just turning golden. When you pull them out, don’t wait—immediately use the back of a spoon to press an indent into the center of each cookie cup. This step is crucial to ensure your pudding stays perfectly nestled in the middle.

Step 2: Preparing the Swirl Filling

While your cookie cups are cooling (this can be the trickiest part to be patient with, trust me), whisk together the instant cheesecake pudding mix and cold 2% milk in a medium bowl. Whisk briskly for 2 minutes until thickened, then let it sit for about 3 minutes to fully set up. Next, split the pudding evenly into two separate small bowls and add 3-4 drops of red food coloring to one and green to the other—don’t hesitate to add more drops if you want vibrant colors. Mixing the right shade is one of the most fun parts—you get instant satisfaction seeing your pudding transform!

Step 3: Swirling the Magic into Cookie Cups

For the swirl effect, spoon each colored pudding side by side into a large zip-top bag without mixing them together. When you snip off a small corner of the bag, squeezing out the pudding forces the colors to flow side-by-side, creating a gorgeous swirl as you fill each cookie indent. This trick was a game changer the first time I tried it—easy and visually impressive! Continue filling every cup, then pop them in the fridge to chill and set. I usually let them rest for at least 30 minutes before serving.

How to Serve Sugar Cookie Pudding Cups with Swirl Filling Recipe

Garnishes

I love topping my pudding cups with a little extra something to add texture and wow-factor. For these, I usually sprinkle finely chopped pistachios or colorful nonpareils right before serving. Fresh mint leaves or a tiny sprinkle of edible glitter make for a stunning touch too—perfect for special occasions or when you want to impress guests without extra fuss.

Side Dishes

Since these cups are sweet and rich, I usually pair them with lighter, refreshing drinks or sides. A cold glass of sparkling water with lemon or a cup of freshly brewed coffee balances the sweetness perfectly. For parties, I like serving alongside a fruit platter—berries and citrus slices bring a fresh bite that complements the creamy texture.

Creative Ways to Present

One holiday I served these in small, clear mini mason jars instead of a muffin pan, and it was such a crowd-pleaser! You can also layer crushed ginger snaps or crumbled shortbread at the bottom for an extra cookie crunch. For a luxe touch, drizzle with a little white chocolate or caramel sauce right before serving—people totally loved this upgrade.

Make Ahead and Storage

Storing Leftovers

If you have leftovers (which honestly rarely happens at my house), store the pudding cups in a single layer in an airtight container in the fridge for up to two days. This keeps the cookies from getting soggy and the pudding fresh. I’ve found that placing parchment paper between layers prevents sticking if you’re stacking containers.

Freezing

I don’t usually freeze these because the pudding texture changes a bit when thawed, but if you want to, freeze the cookie cups without pudding first. Then thaw, fill with fresh pudding swirls right before serving for best results. Trust me, this trick saved me when I needed to prep early!

Reheating

This dessert is really best served chilled, so reheating isn’t necessary. If you want the cookie base a little softer, you can let the cups sit at room temp for 10-15 minutes before enjoying. The swirl filling should stay cool to maintain its creamy texture.

FAQs

Final Thoughts

This Sugar Cookie Pudding Cups with Swirl Filling Recipe truly became a favorite in my home the moment I tried it. It’s such a joy to make, with that satisfying moment when the swirls come together perfectly and you get to watch everyone’s faces light up when they take a bite. If you’re craving a dessert that’s festive, fun, and heaven in every spoonful, I can’t recommend this enough. Go ahead and try it—you’ll be glad you did!

Print