Butternut Squash Cheeseball and a Holiday Cheese Board Recipe

If you’re looking to wow your guests this season, I can’t recommend this Butternut Squash Cheeseball and a Holiday Cheese Board Recipe enough. It’s a cozy, festive twist on the classic cheeseball that brings that warm roasted butternut squash flavor right into the middle of your holiday spread. Honestly, the way the creamy cheeseball pairs with the crunchy, slightly sweet walnuts and fragrant sage makes it an unforgettable centerpiece, and the whole cheese board? It has so many little surprises guests will love. Stick with me, and I’ll walk you through every step so you nail this with ease!

this …

Ingredients You’ll Need

The ingredients here balance richness with bright, earthy notes, especially from sage and nutmeg. When shopping, look for fresh squat and nuts to toast at home – it really boosts the flavor.

• Butternut squash: Choose a firm, medium-sized one for the best texture and natural sweetness.
• Brown butter: Adds a nutty depth and richness you won’t get from regular butter.
• Olive oil: Use a good quality one for frying the sage leaves to crispy perfection.
• Fresh sage: This herb is key for that warm, woodsy aroma, crisped for texture and flavor.
• Cream cheese: Make sure it’s softened to blend smoothly without lumps.
• Parmesan cheese: Grate finely to melt easily into the mix and add savory sharpness.
• Salt, pepper, nutmeg: Season gently; nutmeg enhances the butternut squash’s natural sweetness.
• Walnuts: Toast them lightly to bring out their full flavor before chopping for the coating.
• Additional cheese board items: Merlot soaked cheese, sharp parmesan, honeycomb, hot capicola, kettle corn, marinated olives, roasted cashews, chutney and salsa varieties, pomegranate arils, honey walnuts, whole grain mustard, cornichons, rainbow carrots, pears, grapes, breadsticks, and crackers.

Variations

While I love the classic combo here, you can definitely tweak or swap a few things to make this recipe your own or suit your dietary needs. I like encouraging that kitchen creativity!

• Dairy-free option: Use a soft vegan cream cheese and nutritional yeast to mimic the cheesy flavor—I tried this for a friend and it was surprisingly good!
• Nut swap: Substitute walnuts for pecans or almonds if you want a different crunch or nutty note.
• Herb twist: Try rosemary or thyme instead of sage for a fresh take; fresh herbs really elevate this cheeseball.
• Spice it up: Add a pinch of cayenne or smoked paprika to give your guests a little surprise heat.

How to Make Butternut Squash Cheeseball and a Holiday Cheese Board Recipe

Step 1: Cook the Butternut Squash Till Tender

Start by placing your cubed butternut squash in a saucepan filled with cold water. Bring it to a boil over high heat, then reduce to a simmer and cook for 15-20 minutes until it’s fork-tender. Here’s the trick: drain very well and pat dry if needed — too much water here can make the cheeseball runny. I learned this the hard way once, so be patient!

Step 2: Brown the Butter and Crisp the Sage

While the squash cooks, gently melt your butter in a pan over medium heat until it turns golden brown and aromatic. In the same pan, lightly fry the fresh sage leaves in olive oil for about one minute on each side until crispy, then drain on a paper towel. Those crispy sage leaves will give the cheeseball that perfect herbal crunch people don’t expect.

Step 3: Blend Everything Together Until Smooth

Using a food processor or a stand mixer, combine the cooked butternut squash, brown butter, crispy sage, softened cream cheese, finely grated parmesan, salt, pepper, and freshly grated nutmeg. Pulse until very smooth — no lumps of cream cheese should remain. I usually pulse, check the texture, and pulse again until it feels just right. The smoother, the better this cheeseball will spread and taste.

Step 4: Chill and Shape Your Cheeseball

Scoop the mixture onto a piece of plastic wrap and form it into a nice round ball. Wrap it tightly to hold its shape and refrigerate for at least 30 minutes. Honestly, I like to let it chill overnight so all the flavors marry perfectly, but even half an hour makes a big difference.

Step 5: Coat with Toasted Walnuts

Spread finely chopped toasted walnuts on a plate. Take your chilled cheeseball out of the fridge and roll it gently in the walnuts, pressing lightly to make sure they stick all around. This nutty crust not only adds crunch but also keeps the cheeseball looking elegant and inviting for your cheese board.

Step 6: Build Your Holiday Cheese Board

Lay out the rest of your cheese board goodies: merlot soaked cheese, sharp parmesan, honeycomb, hot capicola, kettle corn, olives, nuts, chutneys, fresh fruit, veggies, crackers, and breadsticks. Don’t stress about perfect order — the beauty is in the natural, festive messiness. Your guests will love digging in!

How to Serve Butternut Squash Cheeseball and a Holiday Cheese Board Recipe

Garnishes

I love topping the cheeseball with a few extra crispy sage leaves for that lovely aromatic crunch and little pomegranate arils for a pop of juicy color and sweetness. It makes the presentation feel extra special and festive.

Side Dishes

This cheeseball pairs beautifully with sliced rainbow carrots, pears, grapes, and some crunchy breadsticks or seeded crackers. It’s also amazing alongside small bowls of mustard and chutneys for guests to customize each bite.

Creative Ways to Present

One year, I arranged the cheeseball in the center of a wooden board surrounded by scattered fresh herbs, mini pumpkins, and edible flowers for a rustic, warm look. Adding honeycomb chunks nearby always impresses—guests love drizzling honey on cheese. Plus, the little unexpected touches keep the board lively and inviting.

Make Ahead and Storage

Storing Leftovers

I tightly wrap the cheeseball in plastic wrap and pop it in an airtight container in the fridge. It keeps beautifully for up to 4 days, perfect if you’re hosting a long holiday weekend or want to prep early.

Freezing

I generally don’t freeze this cheeseball because the texture changes a bit when thawed, but if you must, wrap it super tightly in plastic and foil. Thaw overnight in the fridge and stir gently if needed before serving.

Reheating

This cheeseball is best served chilled or at room temp. If you’re reheating the butternut squash itself for another use, keep it low and slow on the stove, but for the cheeseball, just let it sit out 20 minutes before serving to soften slightly.

FAQs

Final Thoughts

This Butternut Squash Cheeseball and a Holiday Cheese Board Recipe truly holds a special place in my holiday celebrations. It’s one of those recipes I love because it’s both comforting and elegant, and effortlessly brings people together around the table. Give it a try – you’ll enjoy how easy it is to make and how impressed your friends and family will be when they take that first bite. Trust me, your holiday parties will thank you!

Print